Metthetsprofil

Metthetsprofil is a neologism that refers to a profile created by integrating metatheoretical considerations with empirical indicators. It is used to map how theoretical commitments shape observable attributes by summarizing both the underlying assumptions and the measured traits.

Etymology: The term appears to be a compound formed from "metatheoretical" and "profil" (profile), drawing on Germanic language roots common in European academic discourse. It is not widely standardized in any particular field.

Construction: A metthetsprofil typically involves two layers: a metatheoretical layer that records the guiding assumptions (ontological stance, epistemological stance, methodological preferences) and an empirical layer that lists measurable attributes or behaviors. These layers are integrated into a single profile, often using qualitative coding and quantitative scoring.

Applications: Proponents argue it helps compare theories, assess research programs, or design user models that reflect both theory and data. In education and science studies, it may be used as a pedagogical tool to illustrate how theoretical commitments influence interpretation of data.

Limitations and critique: The concept risks ambiguity and inconsistent application. Critics point to difficulties in standardizing the metatheoretical layer and potential biases in weighting components. Privacy concerns may arise if applied to individuals rather than theories.

See also: Metatheory, profiling, theory of science.