Eelretsenseerimise

Eelretsenseerimise, often translated as pre-peer review or preliminary review, is a process sometimes employed in academic publishing and research settings before a formal submission for peer review. Its primary purpose is to provide early feedback on the potential of a research idea, manuscript, or grant proposal. This informal or semi-formal stage can involve receiving input from colleagues, mentors, or internal committees. The goal is to identify significant flaws, suggest improvements, or assess the novelty and feasibility of the work at an early stage, potentially saving time and resources that would otherwise be spent on a full peer review of a less promising submission.

The specific implementation of eelretsenseerimise can vary. In some academic departments, it might involve presenting research in progress at lab meetings or departmental seminars to gauge reactions and gather constructive criticism. In other contexts, it could be a formal requirement by a funding agency or a journal to submit a brief abstract or a preliminary draft for an initial assessment of suitability. This process is not a substitute for formal peer review but rather a complementary step aimed at enhancing the quality and impact of research before it enters the more rigorous evaluation stages. It encourages a proactive approach to research development and can help researchers refine their work based on expert opinions before facing the more critical scrutiny of external peer reviewers.