kiertoarvio

Kiertoarvio is a Finnish term that translates to "circular review" or "round-robin review." It describes a peer review process where a piece of work, such as a manuscript, proposal, or project plan, is reviewed sequentially by a series of individuals. Each reviewer provides their feedback, and then passes the work on to the next reviewer in the designated order. This continues until all reviewers in the cycle have had an opportunity to assess the material.

The primary purpose of a kiertoarvio is to gather diverse perspectives and ensure a thorough evaluation. By having multiple individuals review the same item, potential biases of a single reviewer can be mitigated, and a broader range of expertise can be brought to bear. This method is often employed in academic settings for research papers, grant applications, and student projects. It can also be utilized in professional environments for internal assessments or quality control.

The process typically involves clear guidelines for each reviewer and a defined timeline for completion. After the final reviewer has submitted their feedback, the collective comments are usually consolidated and provided to the author or originator of the work. This allows for a comprehensive understanding of the strengths and weaknesses identified during the review cycle. The kiertoarvio aims for a collaborative and systematic approach to feedback, fostering improvement and refinement of the reviewed item.